Skip to content

Thesis defence

Towards an Integrated Judiciary for the Integrated Administration

Composite Procedures and Their Review by the European Courts

Add to calendar 2026-11-09 15:00 2026-11-09 17:00 Europe/Rome Towards an Integrated Judiciary for the Integrated Administration Sala degli Stemmi Villa Salviati - Castle YYYY-MM-DD
Print

Scheduled dates

Nov 09 2026

15:00 - 17:00 CET

Sala degli Stemmi, Villa Salviati - Castle

Organised by

PhD thesis defence by Ieva Hūna.

The European courts are well-known to struggle with overseeing composite procedures. While the EU and national authorities in composite procedures act as an integrated administration, the Court of Justice and national courts review them as separate judiciaries. Through a doctrinal and conceptual analysis, the thesis shows that this mismatch creates systemic risks for effective judicial protection at every stage of review.

At the admissibility stage, the method for determining the reviewable act and the jurisdiction to review it risks denying access to court. In adjudication, the Court of Justice lacks jurisdiction or procedural instruments to review the entire procedural sequence and address the unlawful conduct of the national authorities. At the enforcement stage, the judgments of national courts do not bind EU authorities and thus might fail to deliver an effective remedy. An analysis of the legal systems of Austria, Latvia and France shows that the diverse national legal systems can exacerbate, mitigate and add to these systemic risks.

The deficient review of composite procedures exposes a conflict at the heart of the EU legal order. The structural principles of autonomy, uniformity, and conferral confine the powers of the European courts to their respective legal orders, while composite procedures require a cross-jurisdictional examination. The European courts’ inability to provide it undermines effective judicial protection and the rule of law, a value enshrined in Article 2 TEU.

Taking a normative approach, this thesis explores solutions to ensure effective judicial protection while respecting these constitutional foundations. It proposes additional cooperation and coordination mechanisms, adjusting the European courts’ jurisdictions, revisiting derivative illegality based on national law, and recognising national judgments at the EU level. It argues that ensuring effective judicial protection in the review of composite procedures requires the European courts to operate as an integrated judiciary, mirroring the integrated administration they oversee.

The Zoom link will be shared upon registration.

Go back to top of the page