Crisis of Expert Knowledge and Authority
Even after years of study and of academic or practical experience, the consequences of most policies are uncertain. While agreement among experts is far greater than realised by the general public, there is legitimate disagreement. Because individuals cannot sensibly invest the effort needed to determine the best policies or their consequences, we must rely on experts. This conclusion, which is at the core of representative democracy, has fallen into deep question.
Since the 2008 financial crisis we have witnessed an erosion of citizens’ trust in experts. Europe has seen populist movements rejecting expert knowledge on a range of issues, from debt, growth, migration and trade to vaccines.
Many who denounce academic experts and mistrust their advice choose instead to follow their own (often self-proclaimed) “experts”. Unfortunately, reliance on charlatans rather than experts can have profoundly negative economic and political consequences.
There are reasons to distrust some experts, since they may err, but rejecting expert knowledge per se is calamitous for society. It is therefore crucial for decision makers and citizens to be able identify reliable experts, and for experts to restore lost credibility. Our program aims to discover the key reforms and mechanisms needed to accomplish this goal.
The questioning of experts has played a significant and not necessarily good role in the current covid-19 pandemic. In countries where governments have been slow to consult with experts in the initial stages of the pandemic effective measures were implemented at a very late stage, with tragic consequences. As governments now move to reopen the economy, again little effort may be made to involve and consult with experts.
The EUI is involved in trying to communicate relevant scientific knowledge to policy-makers through its Covid-19 Knowledge hub. Several members of this research cluster with expertise relevant to the crisis are additionally involved in policy-related communication through the international group Covid-19 Research Conduit. As our Experts research cluster moves forward we expect our experience with this crisis to inform and be informed by our broader study of the role of experts.
Nihan Akhan (ECO)
Damiano Argan (ECO)
David Andrés Cerezo
Anatole Cheysson (ECO)
(EUI Secretary General)
Mustafa Kabe (ECO)
Hanno Kase (ECO)
Konuray Mutluer (ECO)
Piotr Pieniazek (ECO)
Marcin Roter (ECO)
Nicole Stoelinga (ECO)
Stéphane Van Damme on the history of expert crises
(via Zoom). Date and time TBA.
Junze Sun presenting the book Expert Failure by Roger Koppl
Discussion of the role of experts in the Covid-19 crisis (via Zoom)
20 February 2020,
Preliminary meeting to discuss and organize the issues involved with expert knowledge; agreed on the outline of an edited volume